18+ karolherbst , Englisch
@karolherbst@chaos.social avatar

We have to stop declaring any project being generally "better" than others. Or to say that FOSS competes with anything as this is just inherently toxic.

Saying "FOSS project competes with X" also says "FOSS project's main goal is to win". But what does it give you if you win against whatever other FOSS project or commercial software?

And why does it have to be about winning in the first place? I want people to work on cool stuff.

I work in FOSS because it's fun, not to win.

18+ donkeyblam ,
@donkeyblam@tech.lgbt avatar

@karolherbst It's an interesting point but I kind of disagree, you really can have things better or worse than eachother, and part of the fun is in winning!

18+ karolherbst OP ,
@karolherbst@chaos.social avatar

@donkeyblam so here is the thing. I haven't said there isn't, simply that we shouldn't assume it.

Some maintainers obviously want to create something better than commercial/closed source software. And that's entirely fine.

Just not everybody is like that.

18+ aks ,
@aks@scalie.zone avatar

@karolherbst

I want to win.. together against proprietary stuff ;)

18+ karolherbst OP ,
@karolherbst@chaos.social avatar

@aks yeah and that's totally fine :)

I'm not saying that it wouldn't be great, just we have to be careful with our expectations towards maintainers.

If individual ones want to compete with everything and the world, sure, that's one motivation. But a lot also just do it for fun or because they saw something missing and just worked on it.

It becomes a problem once users arrive expecting a project to compete, where that's not the maintainers motivation at all.

18+ aks ,
@aks@scalie.zone avatar

@karolherbst indeed!

I just want to help KDE desktop and apps to be good experience to everyone, in way or another.

18+ ThePlant ,
@ThePlant@mastodon.social avatar

@karolherbst Well, one way to look at it is that competition can be pretty fun, it all depends on how the person doing the thing looks at the word

18+ karolherbst OP ,
@karolherbst@chaos.social avatar

@ThePlant for sure, and I think there are a lot of people in FOSS doing it to be better than commercial software.

And that's all fine, we just have to be careful to not assume that "you compete with commercial software" is generally true.

  • Alle
  • Abonniert
  • Moderiert
  • Favoriten
  • random
  • haupteingang
  • Alle Magazine