Plötzlich bilden sich im Nacken rötliche Flecken mit ringförmig verdicktem Rand, die rotgereizten Stellen schuppen und jucken. Die Flecken können sich verteilen, auf dem Kopf und über den Körper, in schlimmen Fällen führen sie zu eitrigen Abszessen und Haarausfall....
Also, ich finde es ja gut, den Nazis so wenig Kulturgut, wie möglich zu lassen. Schlimm genug, dass Viking Metal, der Vorname "Adolph" und ein ganz normaler Oberlippenbart schon von denen verseucht wurde.
Alt text: O'RLY? generated book cover with a donkey, navy blue accent, header: "It's only free if you don't value your time", title: "Handling Arch Linux Failures", subtitle: "Mom, please cancel my today's agenda!"
I'm not claiming he denounced his own ideas, but rather the people claiming to represent marxism. I'm not claiming that anyone worshipped Marx, but that they misunderstood his work.
No, sorry. Claiming that a state can work to not enslave the masses, just because "the right people" are in charge is the actual idealism.
Your claim about representation is wrong, too. Sorry. Anarchist regions have collapsed due to external military pressure. You should read a book on how well the material conditions improved in Catalonia. Sorry, your claims about anarghist regions failing to improve their material condition runs counter to reality and to the actual Marxist theory (that only the people can free themselves, etc.)
The whole planned economy was bogus. What do you think a class is?
Again, you claim that you know anything about anarchist theory and show time and time again that you don't have the slightest of an idea.
Yes, all of the Marxists have failed to understand Marx, it is in fact *Prunebutt* who resurrected Marx and got him to denounce everyone who used his ideas.
Ok, I've read it and I'm not impressed. The post on hexbear tries to act as if they were seriously considering the anarchist point of view, they are constantly being disingenuous.
The biggest point of critique againstEngels is that he is effectively strawmanning anti-authoritarians, by using a definition of authority that differs from the anarchist definition in a fundamental way. While the hexbear author acknowledges that fact in the beginning and seems to take the (IMHO flawed) definition of the anarchist's critique at face value, he repeats the same mistake that Engels did and takes Engels' definition as the only logical one.
They aren't engaging with the definition in a serious way. That is my point.
I follow a different definition, that's more complete, IMHO: Authority is the monopolization of power from the hands of the many to the hands of the few. With that definition, which is compatible with the bulk of anarchist theory, "On authority" is nothing, but the incoherent ramblings of someone with too much personal beef.
The hexbear author not once seriously engages with any of the two viewpoints given in the anarchist rebuttal. They give this example of a robbery, where they try to reach a point with the anarchist's definition and call it absurd. The only reason, they do so, is begause in the middle of their argument, they switch definitions back to Engels' definition. If I change the preconditions in the middle of my logical chain, shit will get goofy. Duh.
You mean the definition of authority that the video you linked as a rebuttal is based on? Because that is the one that is being critiqued.
No. The video and the essay huse different definitions. You didn't watch the -ideo, or didn't listen to it, properly.
The argument is that the alternate definition that the anarchist proposes is incoherent.
The hexbear author fails to do so and doesn't properly represent the anarchist's essay's point of view.
Engels created a straw-man. No anti-authoritarian thinks that necessity, or self-defense is authority. Therefore, they don't argue against necessity, or self-defense.
The video used the same definition. I never claimed it was congruent with the essay on the anarchist library.
Lol, no. Power was incredibly monopolized by the bolsheviki and their Komisars.
I read the anarchist rebuttal. It made clear that force and authority are different things. The robbery example would not be authority, but force, according to the anarchist essay. The hexbear author didn't understand that, or misrepresented the anarchist.
It's ok, if you didn't get the video. How is steam a monopolization of power?
Do you know the difference between a free and an imperative mandate? If not, then you don't understand the anarchist's critique.
How would you know? You didn't fucking read it, if you didn't source the argument of "authority is created through unquestioning obedience"!
I did read both the anarchist's rebuttal and the hexbear comment (as far as I could stomach). I don't completely agree with the anarchist's rebuttal, which is why I didn't share it. The hexbear bloke didn't genuinely take the anarchist's proposal seriously, as I've explained several times now.
There are literally those who think self defense is authority but justifiable authority, did you read the "Problems with "On Authority""? No?
That's not what the essay's author claims. The essay's author doesn't view self-defense as "blind obedience", hence they don't think it is authority. Please stop misrepresenting stuff, it's getting exhausting.
It's no use arguing, if we both don't accept each other's definition of authority. You claim that the anarchist definition is incomplete, which you try to prove with Engels' definition. I say that no anti-authoritarian uses the same definition as Engels and the cycle continues.
Just admit that you don't want to consider anarchist perspectives. It would save you a lot of time.
Low Fade, Undercut, juckende Kopfhaut: Hautpilz verbreitet sich durch Trendfrisuren im Barbershop ( www.spiegel.de )
Plötzlich bilden sich im Nacken rötliche Flecken mit ringförmig verdicktem Rand, die rotgereizten Stellen schuppen und jucken. Die Flecken können sich verteilen, auf dem Kopf und über den Körper, in schlimmen Fällen führen sie zu eitrigen Abszessen und Haarausfall....
ich👨⚕️🚫👨⚖️iel
That is an act of cruelty towards the poor pokémon ( pawb.social ) Englisch
Hey there both good ( lemmy.world )
ich🖤iel ( infosec.pub )
https://www.tagesschau.de/inland/innenpolitik/cdu-landtagswahlen-100.html
[AI image] She pretty cute though tbh. ( lemmy.world ) Englisch
https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/096a2758-d72e-4904-9395-e343ffaf1b5a.png...
low effort maymay ( programming.dev )
Alt text: O'RLY? generated book cover with a donkey, navy blue accent, header: "It's only free if you don't value your time", title: "Handling Arch Linux Failures", subtitle: "Mom, please cancel my today's agenda!"
ich🇬🇷iel
Holla, die Waldfee
Ich🐮🔨😵iel
Stonehenge sprayed with paint by environmental protesters ( www.dw.com ) Englisch
for all the "anti-authoritarians" out there
ich🤡iel ( infosec.pub )
Eigentlich lieben alle die SPD