Wishing you guys a happy civil war 2 ( lemmy.world )

Buttons , vor 6 Monaten

The Colorado lower court also found it was an insurrection, but that an insurrection didn't disqualify a person from running for President (because of some very specific wording in the
constitution).

So both sides in the case appealed and now here we are.

shalafi , vor 6 Monaten

Knowing it would be appealed, no matter the ruling, the lower court found it was an insurrection. The next court had to take that as a factual finding. They could not argue or retry that question. It is now a legal fact.

Brilliant move! That judge took one for the team, called a coward and a traitor. And you see what we have here today. (insert wasted.meme)

The_Vampire , vor 6 Monaten

That's not how American courts work? The upper court can find issue with practically anything it likes.

Reddfugee42 , vor 6 Monaten

That's not how American courts work?

Nope. The court of appeals can find fault with the methods, procedure, precedent etc but not the facts.

(Also, that's not how question marks work.)

The_Vampire , vor 6 Monaten

But here's the thing: they could easily say the method that led to the finding is wrong. It's not a fact.

Madison420 , vor 6 Monaten

If it's decided by the lower court it is held as fact. It may not in your opinion be correct but it is verifiably a fact at this point.